Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.


Table of Content Zone
locationtop
styledisc

Table of Contents
outlinetrue
indent25px
stylenone

Terminology

Expand

Wet Etching - Substrates are immersed in a reactive solution (etchant). The layer to be etched is removed by chemical reaction or by dissolution. The reaction products must be soluble and are carried away by the etchant solution.  Generally, wet etching is isotropic.

Dry Etching - Substrates are immersed in a reactive gas (plasma). The layer to be etched is removed by chemical reactions and/or physical means (ion bombardment). The reaction products must be volatile and are carried away in the gas stream.

      • Plasma Etching - Typically high pressure, no ion bombardment.  (Substrate is placed on a grounded electrode)
      • Reactive Ion Etching - Typically lower pressures, ion bombardment. (Substrate is placed on a powered electrode)

Anisotropic Etch - Etch rate is not equal in all directions.

Isotropic Etch - Etch rate is equal in all directions.

Etching - The process by which material is removed from a surface.

Mask - Used to protect regions of the wafer surface. Examples include photoresist, Ni, Cr, or oxide layer.

Selectivity - The ratio of etch rate of film to etch rate of substrate or mask.

Aspect Ratio - Ratio of depth to width of an etched feature.

Plasma - Partially ionized gas containing an equal number of positive and negative charges, as well as some other number of none ionized gas particles. 

Glow Discharge - Globally neutral, but contains regions of net positive and negative charge. (Many thin film processes utilize glow discharges, but “plasma” and “glow discharge” are often used interchangeably)

...

Expand


Effects of Cl2 and Fluorine Chemistry on Chamber Walls and Etch Parameters

New chamber walls conditioning and cleaning strategies to improve the stability of plasma processes

Changes in the chamber wall conditions (e.g. chemical composition) are identified as being one important cause of process drifts such as changes in etch rates, etching profiles, etching selectivity or etching uniformity across the wafer. As the reactor wall conditions are modified due to the deposition or removal of etch products, the plasma chemistry changes, which in turn modifies the process performances. Controlling the reactor wall conditions and their stability is of primary concern when trying to create repeatable processes.

In the plot to the right, the first column (a) represents a new, unaltered, Al2O3 chamber wall. In the second column (b), we see the effect of Chlorine etching. There is a clear build up of Silicon Oxychloride layers, as well as, Cl+Br bonded to the wall. The third column (c) represents an 80s fluorine etch following the chlorine etch. We see that the Silicon Oxychloride film and Cl+Br bonds have been removed and we are left with a thin fluorinated aluminum layer. Column (d) represents subsequent fluorine etches totaling 20 minutes of plasma exposure. We see that the fluorinated aluminum layer is building but surface chemistry has not changed.

This will lead to several issues including flake off of AlxFy particles on the wafer and process drifts (due both to the progressive growth of AlF material on the SiO2 windows and to the release of F atoms from the chamber walls during the etching process). 

Plasma chemistry can be used to control the conditioning of the chamber. Transitions from chlorine to fluorine and visa versa require different approaches, see below for details.

Transition from Fluorine to Chlorine etch chemistry

Observed Effects

Klimecky_JVSTA_wfigs.pdf

A thin film of silicon oxychloride grows on the chamber walls during Chlorine plasma etches. Fluorine etch chemistry will quickly strip away the thin oxychloride film from chamber walls resulting in significant transient effects in plasma density and real-time etch rate when transitioning back to chlorine etch chemistry. The root cause of these transients is assumed to be a result of dynamic oxychloride layer build-up processes at the chamber walls.

As shown in the plot to the right, Chlorine etch rate will be lower when transitioning from Fluorine etch back to Chlorine etching.

Chlorine etch rate will also be lower when following a chamber mechanical clean as this can also strip the oxychloride film from the chamber walls.


Black trace represents a well seasoned chamber.

Green trace represents first Chlorine etch after Fluorine etch.

Proposed Mechanism for Effects

The transient effects of oxychloride film buildup persist until it has achieved a steady state creation/loss ratio. At this point the Chlorine etch conditions become constant. In the paper referenced, it is suggested that transient effects are eliminated after approximately 300 seconds of Chlorine etching.

The chamber seasoning alters recombination rates at the walls, which affects both the neutral species density and the plasma density as shown in the plot to the right. The plot shows that SiCl4 is low and increasing at the start of first Chlorine etch after a Fluorine etching. SiCl4 is the primary etch product of Si etched in Cl2 chemistry and is a good indicator of real time etch rate.

 

Black trace represents a well seasoned chamber.

Green trace represents first Chlorine etch after Fluorine etch.

Recommended Chlorine Etch Chamber Preparation

In our shared facility, it is often difficult to know exactly what has happened in the chamber before you arrived to use the tool. In addition, most users are more concerned with final depth of their etch rather than efficiency of time usage. For these reasons, it is best to return the chamber to a known condition before you begin your processing. Since the transient effects discussed above are consistent and predictable, we can generate a recipe that will bring the chamber to a stable condition before Chlorine etching.

Before beginning your Chlorine etch, it is best to strip the oxychloride film from the chamber walls and bring the chamber walls back to a known starting point. Do this by running the clean and coat recipe available at the tool.

Once returned to the known starting point, you may proceed with your Chlorine etch as usual.

Example Recipe for Panasonic E620 (other tool recipes may vary from this but purpose is the same)

Recipe Step

TCP Coil Power (Watt)

Platen Power (Watt)

Gas 1 (sccm)

Gas 2 (sccm)

Pressure (mTorr)

Time (seconds)

1. Strip and Clean

8000CF4 > 50O2 > 4022.5900
2. Chamber Purge00N2 > 100NA22.530
3. Grow Oxychloride Film on chamber walls4000Cl2 > 50NA22.5300


Chlorine etch depth achieved for first three etches after Fluorine etching. Samples etched for 30 seconds each, significant etch rate increase for each sample. This is known as the "First Wafer Effect" in industry.

The etch rate is increasing for each run as the wall seasons with
oxychloride buildup and the recombination rate goes down.

Transition from Chlorine to Fluorine etch chemistry

Observed Effects

During Chlorine plasma etches a thin film of silicon oxychloride grows on the chamber walls. Fluorine etch chemistry will strip away the thin oxychloride film from chamber walls resulting in significant transient effects in plasma density and real-time etch rate when transitioning back to fluorine etch chemistry. The root cause of these transients is assumed to be a result of dynamic oxychloride layer stripping processes at the chamber walls and subsequent build up of Al-F layers.

The oxychloride stripping effects of fluorine etch plasma are short lived and typically last less than a minute. The subsequent build up of Al-F layers can take a few minutes to stabilize.

Black trace represents a Cl2 seasoned chamber.

Green trace represents first Chlorine etch after Fluorine etching, indicating plasma losses due to replacing oxychloride film that was stripped in a 30 second fluorine etch.

Proposed Mechanism for Effects

The transient effects of oxychloride film stripping persist until the film has been removed. At this point the fluorine etch conditions become constant. In the paper referenced, it is suggested that transient effects are eliminated after approximately 30 seconds of fluorine etching.

The chamber seasoning alters recombination rates at the walls, which affects both the neutral species density and the plasma density as shown in the plot to the right. The plot shows that SiCl4 is low and increasing at the start of first Chlorine etch after a Fluorine etching. SiCl4 is the primary etch product of Si etched in Cl2 chemistry and indicates low etch rate due to plasma losses.

 

Black trace represents a Cl2 seasoned chamber.

Green trace represents first Chlorine etch after Fluorine etching, indicating low etch product due to replacing oxychloride film that was stripped in a 30 second fluorine etch.


Recommended Fluorine Etch Chamber Preparation

In our shared facility, it is often difficult to know exactly what has happened in the chamber before you arrived to use the tool. In addition, most users are more concerned with final depth of their etch rather than efficiency of time usage. For these reasons, it is best to return the chamber to a known condition before you begin your processing. Since the transient effects discussed above are consistent and predictable, we can generate a recipe that will bring the chamber to a stable condition before fluorine etching.

Before beginning your fluorine etch, it is best to strip the oxychloride film from the chamber walls and bring the chamber walls back to a known starting point. Do this by running the chamber clean recipe available at the tool.

Once returned to the known starting point, you may proceed with your fluorine etch as usual.

Example Recipe for Panasonic E620 (other tool recipes may vary from this but purpose is the same)

Recipe Step

TCP Coil Power (Watt)

Platen Power (Watt)

Gas 1 (sccm)

Gas 2 (sccm)

Pressure (mTorr)

Time (seconds)

1. Initial Step

7000CF4 > 50O2 > 4037.55
2. Strip and Clean7000CF4 > 50O2 > 4037.530
3. N2 Purge1000N2 > 100NA18.810


Chlorine etch depth achieved for first three etches after Fluorine etching. The etch rate is increasing for each run as the wall seasons with oxychloride buildup and the recombination rate goes down, indicating previous fluorine etch stripped oxychloride film.


...

Oxford Plama Etching Media Center


General Materials

...

Aluminum Oxide

Expand

From a quick search, seems to be typically etched in high density plasmas with a chlorine based chemistry - JCW

The ETCH Mechanism for Al2O3 in Fluorine and Chlorine Based RF Dry Etch Plasmas

Temperature dependence on dry etching of Al2O3 thin films in BCl3/Cl2/Ar plasma

Dry Etching of Al2O3 Thin Films in O2/BCl3/Ar Inductively Coupled Plasma

"Aluminum Oxide", Oxford Instruments

General - Will it etch

...

Materials can generally be etched in the RIEs as long as they form volatile byproducts, or products for which the vapor pressure (at the temperature of the etch) is higher than the pressure of the chamber.

...

- Will it etch?


Excerpt

Materials can generally be etched in the RIEs as long as they form volatile byproducts, or products for which the vapor pressure (at the temperature of the etch) is higher than the pressure of the chamber.

Etching is very complicated and this will be massive oversimplification...but generally volatile byproducts can be determined from literature, or as a fallback, the CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics Online, (4) Properties of the Elements & Inorganics, Physical Constants of Inorganic Compounds: https://hbcp.chemnetbase.com/faces/documents/04_02/04_02_0001.xhtml. From there, click "Go to Interactive Table", and find products that may be formed (i.e. chloride, fluorides, oxides, depending on the gasses). A compound is deemed volatile if it has a boiling point at a reasonable temperature range for the temperature and pressure of the system. Note that at lower pressures, boiling points decrease, so these are just a good staring point reference.

As a VERY general rule of thumb, anything with a boiling point (tbp) < 185 C will be volatile in the ICP RIEs.

As an example, aluminum chloride is volatile, and aluminum fluoride and aluminum are not.

Neither Copper chloride or copper fluoride is volatile, which is why it is not allowed in any chamber:

Byproducts of silicon are very volatile:

Image Removed

Image Removed

Many times different fluorides/chlorides of the same material will have drastically different boiling points. It's important to research which will be formed in the plasma. Titanium is a good example of this, with TiCl2  and TiCl3 being non-volatile, and TiCl4 being volatile:

Image Removed

Image Removed

Image Removedare very volatile:

Image Added

Image Added

Many times different fluorides/chlorides of the same material will have drastically different boiling points. It's important to research which will be formed in the plasma. Titanium is a good example of this, with TiCl2  and TiCl3 being non-volatile, and TiCl4 being volatile:

Image Added

Image Added

Image Added

A selection of potentially dry-etchable materials

Information from "Physical Constants of Organic Compounds," in CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 104th Edition (Internet Version 2023), John R. Rumble, ed., CRC Press/Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton, FL. Link.

Note: The presence of a material here does not mean your etch will work or that you should etch this material in a particular system. It is only for reference.


MaterialGas TypeVolatile Etch Byproduct - NameVolatile Etch Byproduct - FormulaCASBoiling Point (ºC)Selected reaction and solubility notes
RutheniumOxygenRuthenium tetroxideRuO420427-56-940slightly soluble in H2O; reacts with ethanol
BoronFluorineTrifluoroboraneBF37637-07-2-99.9soluble in H2O
SiliconFluorineSilicon tetrafluorideSiF47783-61-1-86reacts with H2O
GermaniumFluorineGermanium tetrafluorideGeF47783-58-6-36.5 (sublimation point)reacts with H2O
TungstenFluorineTungsten hexafluorideWF67783-82-617.1reacts with H2O; very soluble in cyclohexane
RheniumFluorineRhenium hexafluorideReF610049-17-933.8soluble in HNO3
MolybdenumFluorineMolybdenum hexafluorideMoF67783-77-934.0reacts with H2O; very soluble in hexane
OsmiumFluorineOsmium hexafluorideOsF613768-38-247.5reacts with H2O
VanadiumFluorineVanadium pentafluorideVF57783-72-448.3reacts with H2O
IridiumFluorineIridium hexafluorideIrF67783-75-753.6reacts with H2O
ArsenicFluorineArsenic trifluorideAsF37784-35-257.13reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol
PlatinumFluorinePlatinum hexafluoridePtF613693-05-569.1
RheniumFluorineRhenium heptafluorideReF717029-21-973.7
SeleniumFluorineSelenium tetrafluorideSeF413465-66-2101.6reacts with H2O; very soluble in ethanol
TinFluorineStannic chlorideSnCl47646-78-8114.15reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol and acetone
ChromiumFluorineChromium(V) fluorideCrF514884-42-5117reacts with H2O
AntimonyFluorineAntimony pentafluorideSbF57783-70-2141reacts with H2O
TantalumFluorineTantalum pentafluorideTaF57783-71-3229.5soluble in H2O and ethanol
NiobiumFluorineNiobium pentafluorideNbF57783-68-8239reacts with H2O
BoronChlorineTrichloroboraneBCl310294-34-512.5reacts with H2O and ethanol
SiliconChlorineSilicon tetrachlorideSiCl410026-04-757.65reacts with H2O
GermaniumChlorineGermanium tetrachlorideGeCl410038-98-986.55reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol
ArsenicChlorineArsenic trichlorideAsCl37784-34-1130
TitaniumChlorineTitanium tetrachlorideTiCl47550-45-0136.45reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol
VanadiumChlorineVanadium tetrachlorideVCl47632-51-1151reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol
AluminumChlorineAluminum trichlorideAlCl37446-70-0180 (sublimation point)
GalliumChlorineGallium trichlorideGaCl313450-90-3201
TantalumChlorineTantalum pentachlorideTaCl57721-01-9239reacts with H2O; soluble in ethanol
NiobiumChlorineNiobium pentachlorideNbCl510026-12-7247.4reacts with H2O
Iron (maybe)ChlorineIron(III) chlorideFeCl37705-08-0316soluble in ethanol and acetone

A selection of likely non-dry-etchable materials

Notable materials that can be deposited at Birck but not chemically dry etched at Birck:

Ag, Au, Co, Cu, Er, ITO (Indium), Mg, Mn, Ni, Pd, Sc


All of these except Au may be etched (with ion milling, a physical process rather than chemical) in the AJA ICP Argon Ion Mill Etcher.

Specific Materials

Aluminum Oxide

Expand

From a quick search, seems to be typically etched in high density plasmas with a chlorine based chemistry - JCW

The ETCH Mechanism for Al2O3 in Fluorine and Chlorine Based RF Dry Etch Plasmas

Temperature dependence on dry etching of Al2O3 thin films in BCl3/Cl2/Ar plasma

Dry Etching of Al2O3 Thin Films in O2/BCl3/Ar Inductively Coupled Plasma

"Aluminum Oxide", Oxford Instruments

Mounting

Small samples may be mounted to carrier wafers with Crystalbond 555 HMP. More info here: A09_18.pdf and 821-1-2-3-4-6-TN.pdf

...